Great for a 2 year old and up because under that age they just put it in their mouth.Bought these for my great-niece at 10 months, she loves squishing them and pulling on the tails.I bought these for my 4 month old babies and they have loved them from day 1! They make a crinkle sound when played with and my kids love it. Now that my babies are closer to 8 months, they actually like to look at the pages more and observe the animals. They obviously love to suck and bite on the different tails as well.These have held up great and they are very good quality. In regards to the lady who says they are a choking hazard, I have no clue how her baby would’ve bit a piece off, unless her husband took a bite at it first.These are the safest toys we have and it’s the only toy that our girls still like. All the others they have got bored of quickly. And of course they make great books, but for now we just let them suck and play with these, they are great for traveling or just leaving in the car seat.Bought these for the grandbabies this past Christmas. They are perfect for infants and toddlers as there are no pages to rip. All fabric is high quality, the stitching is strong and well done. The colors are bright and attractive, the artwork captures their attention. The little tails are something tiny hand like to grab onto, and they foster fine motor skills. The are attracted to the crinkling sound the pages make. I've seen a lot of the cloth books for wee ones, but these are definitely a step above.These make great gifts and we keep one in our own car for when the kiddos ride with us, to keep them occupied and busy.Highly recommend.I searched hard for MADE IN USA.Belens and Amazon seemed to mislead in descriptions, with no mention of made in China.I am returning these books.We love these books! They make a crinkly noise along with one page in each book has a squeaker. Perfect for my young baby to play with before she was interested in toys.Our granddaughter loves these books & really love the quality. They wash up in the washer really well!!!Colorful and cute. The quality of tails are good. The first page has plastic paper inside which could make noise to attract baby’s attention. One thing I’m not so happy about is the sound making part in one of the book is broken, but it is just a minor issue.Second time buying cloth books for my niece because she loved the first set! These books are fun and safe for little toddler, and it's interesting to play with. I liked the fine details of this set of cloth book, everything were well made and put together. My niece can't read yet so she's just enjoying the tails as toys, and I'm sure she can enjoy it a different way when she learns to read. Bright color and soft to the touch!Colourful pictures and crinkly noises keep baby entertained. Clearly not designed by a native English speaker with any knowledge of animals though. Not all the animals from the jungle actually live in the jungle. Same goes for the rainforest book. Not to mention the odd "Rain forest" title.These were a hit! However the horse tail started to fall apart. For safety reasons I took off the horse tail and now the horse is tail-less. Also the accuracy of the animals and the habitat they live in is so off... for example, raccoons do not live in the rainforest... lol not that my son even understands, but still.Good quality books. 5 month old loves them. They crinkle and the tails are different textures and some tails have a squeaker in them. Will buy some as gifts in the futureMy baby loved this item!